23 responses

  1. mini implants las vegas
    February 13, 2014

    You’re in simple fact a great webmaster. The web page running rate can be extraordinary. Them type of senses that you are carrying out virtually any exceptional strategy. Furthermore, This subject matter usually are masterwork. you could have conducted a fantastic hobby on this make any difference!

    Reply

  2. Mary @ Green Global Travel
    January 12, 2014

    Talon, I think you summed up what it means to be an American beautifully. I didn’t realize until I started traveling that not everyone thinks/believes that “if you want something bad enough and are willing to work hard to achieve it, you can do and be anything you want.” While I believe that statement is wonderful, I think it also causes a tremendous amount of discontent for Americans because it’s not always true. Thanks for helping to clarify a difficult question.

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 13, 2014

      You are definitely correct that it isn’t always true. Sometimes it seems like it’s even less true now than when I was younger.

      Reply

  3. Shelly
    January 11, 2014

    I do consider my nationality while living at home- all the time! I am Canadian, and we tend to analyse cultures and their blessings constantly, because we are made up of thousands of different cultures. When I travel and people hear me speak, if they don’t know many North Americans, they’ll think I’m American. It is only when they get to chat with me and talk about culture that they understand that I am from Canada. People assume that my own politics are the same as my country’s, and usually, they assume most of my beliefs align with American politics…wrong on both accounts! I usually consider myself a global citizen. At home, I teach international literature, and it’s analysis of humans, and I also teach Canadian lit and it’s analysis – I do have to say, there are differences- not better/worse, but beautiful, human differences- thank goodness we’re not all the same!

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 12, 2014

      And I love celebrating those differences. They are part of what makes the world so exciting!

      Reply

  4. Sam
    January 9, 2014

    Interesting. I, perhaps unusually, feel no patriotism towards my country of birth whatsoever (for the record, I’m British). For me, i *is* just the nationality on my passport, and something I’m neither proud nor ashamed of. It’s convenient, and I’m grateful for having this citizenship over many others in terms of the freedom of movement that grants me, but beyond that, it’s more or less meaningless to me.

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 10, 2014

      I had never really thought about it until he asked me the question. I, too, value my passport because it’s one of the top ones to have for travel. I don’t generally feel all that connected to my nationality and never really have. To me it’s such a small piece of who I am compared to all the other stuff.

      Reply

  5. wandering educators
    January 9, 2014

    I think being an American really hits home when you’re overseas and being asked. When you’re home, you don’t even think about it! To me, it means choices, really. Not that those aren’t available elsewhere, but that our “american dream” promotes that. Whether that really happens? Depends on circumstances, I think.

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 10, 2014

      Definitely a multifaceted question. Yeah, I don’t think people really consider their nationality when they’re at home. You don’t really realize the cultural differences and issues until you’re in a foreign environment.

      Reply

  6. Carol Reese
    January 9, 2014

    I’ve not had the privilege of traveling overseas, but I’m going to relate here something I noticed when we moved from Texas to Georgia, because I think it’s the same sort of thing others in this discussion have observed on a global scale. I’ve lived in Pennsylvania, California, Utah, Texas, Georgia, and now Alabama. I’ve visited several other states. While each state and/or region has particular cultural characteristicss, in the long run, there are many more similarities than diffences. I really hadn’t noticed it much before, but when we moved from Texas to Georgia, it struck me as it had not before. Maybe it was because I was older and didn’t have pressing things like very small children to deal with. The kids were older and also noticed many of the same things I did. Over this last summer, we visited 6 National Parks as well as National/State parks in Arizona, California, and Oregon. We met many visitors from around the world – France, Germany, Australia, Lithuania, Italy, Korea, and more. We managed, sometimes with difficulty, to communicate with them. When we did manage to make ourselves understood, we were all pleased. There were laughs over my high school French, and their high school English. All in all, however, we were all just people, and the differences were far less important than the similarities. And I suspect that’s true all over the world, but unfortunately, many people don’t realize that and choose to focus on the differences, which is sad.

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 9, 2014

      Cultural identity is an interesting thing, and cultures can vary widely from city to city much less state to state.

      Reply

  7. Alecs Variny
    January 8, 2014

    * Czech Republic

    Reply

  8. Alecs Variny
    January 8, 2014

    I believe that an American is a person born in the USA. Your first instinct was probably the one I agree with. I was born in Romania but I am an American citizen. Am I an American? Yes, if you look at my passport. Not really if you ask me. I chose to live here for many reasons but it doesn’t make me an American. The more I travel, the more I see that the only real proof of what you are is where you were born. You may love living in the Check Republic and you’ll stay there for 20 years. Will you still be an American? Probably… You might not agree with a lot of things but I think that being a global citizen is no good substitution for nationality. I go often back to Romania and I feel strange at times, I don’t always feel at home or that I belong (I left when I was 17) but I will never be able to say to anyone that I am an American. Because it’s not true. I chose to live there and I’m great full that I can. However, think of this… If I am traveling to a different country, not the one I was born in and not the one I live in, I always say that I am an American. And I feel that way. But when I am in my native country or in the country that I live, there is only one correct answer, I am Romanian. It’s weird and I’m not sure how other people who have lived in two cultures for longer periods of time feel.

    Reply

    • Kelly
      January 9, 2014

      With due respect, Alecs, I don’t think place of birth necessarily forms identity. I think it is more accurate to say that you are more likely to culturally identify with the culture in which you lived during your formative years. In your case, you lived in Romania for 17 years – birth to almost-adulthood.

      My two children were born in another country and came here as infants when I adopted them. While they may look like the majority racial identify of their birth country, they are culturally American and clearly identify as such. When we’ve returned to their birth country, the citizens there clearly identify them as American – because even though they have learned the language of their birth country, and we’ve worked hard to become a dual-culture family, the fact is that the only culture they’ve really only known on a deep level is American.

      Reply

      • Alecs Variny
        January 9, 2014

        I would be curious to know how they feel. I understand your point of view and it make sense, for you, but it’s an interesting thing that is locked deep into your heart, the place you were born. I don’t think about it everyday and I go on about my life normally, but when you have to stop and think… when someone asks you where are you from, it’s different than when they ask where were you born… In my opinion. Also, I think that the fact that United States it’s a melting pot of people and cultures, it makes it easier to say I’m an American. Because you can. Because that’s what it is at the base of the country, it’s immigrants. I wonder if it is the other way around, if as an American you were to move to a different country, would it be as easily accepted?

        Reply

      • Talon Windwalker
        January 9, 2014

        Yes, there’s a big difference between nationality and cultural identity for sure!

        Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 9, 2014

      I don’t see being a global citizen as a substitution for nationality. To me it’s a broader perspective of feeling connected to places all over the world. Someone who has never left their home state is more likely to not feel as deeply for the issues going on around the world, whereas when there was destruction in the Philippines I felt it more deeply because I’ve been there and spent time with locals. The immigration plight of Romanians and Bulgarians in the EU would probably not affect me or touch me as deeply had I not spent 3 months living there and developing a love for the country and its people.

      Reply

  9. Jack
    January 8, 2014

    It’s an interesting question… for anyone of any nationality.

    I’m no patriot to my own country but I believe that part of who I am has been shaped by the history and character of where I was born. I don’t have a problem with that. I love the fact that we’re all different in some way – it’s what makes experiencing new places and cultures such a pleasure.

    I had a friend who used to say ‘what a boring place the world would be if we were all the same’.

    As the French say ‘vive la différence’.

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 9, 2014

      Amen to that! Attempting to homogenize a culture is so sad to me. Those differences should be celebrated!

      Reply

  10. Val-This Way To Paradise
    January 8, 2014

    Great article. I think for me, too, I don’t really identify with many of the things that America seems to represent anymore like consumerism and governmental politics. I prefer to think of myself as a global citizen!

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 8, 2014

      I think global citizens are the ones who will change the world. 😉

      Reply

  11. Dyanne@TravelnLass
    January 8, 2014

    Most interesting (as usual) Talon, and it’s a question that reliably comes up frequently as we Americans travel the globe.

    But I must say, coincidentally – your question comes at a time when – just recently it dawned on me that…

    After just 2+ years of living as an expat – I no longer think of myself as an “American”. Indeed, the lines between everyone I meet – be they locals or fellow travelers/expats – just don’t seem to matter to me much. Nationalities just disappear, and I think of folks around me simply as “people”. “Global citizens” if you will – that happen to share the same (exceedingly fragile) Planet.

    In short, I feel blessed that I finally understand what Msr. Lennon meant by: “Imagine there’s no countries…”

    Reply

    • Talon Windwalker
      January 8, 2014

      I very much agree. I’ve never really felt all that connected to the American culture to begin with, but the longer we’re away the more global I feel. Which is what I wanted for Tigger. I didn’t want his vision of the world to be a myopic nationalized one but instead to see himself more as a global citizen.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop